The Impact of Promotion Bias

Promotion decisions have a significant impact on an individual's career trajectory and sense of belonging within an organisation. Being passed over for a well-deserved promotion can demotivate employees, leading to decreased productivity and increased turnover intentions. Moreover, promotion practices that favour certain groups over others contribute to systemic inequalities and reinforce biases, impacting the diverse talent pipeline in the long run.

Recent studies on UK workplaces highlight the persistent bias and barriers faced by underrepresented groups when it comes to career progression. The 2022 McKinsey report, "Diversity wins: Inclusion matters," found that while ethnic minority representation has increased at the entry level across organisations, this diversity decreases substantially at senior levels. This indicates a clear block in the talent pipeline for ethnic minorities, with promotion practices playing a pivotal role. Similarly, research by the CIPD and YouGov revealed that 38% of UK employees from ethnic minority backgrounds feel their race or ethnicity has hindered their career progression, compared to just 2% of white employees who feel their background has negatively impacted their careers.

Gender bias also remains prevalent in promotion decisions. The World Economic Forum's "Global Gender Gap Report 2022" ranked the UK a disappointing 51st out of 146 countries for economic participation and opportunity, with women still facing significant barriers to career advancement. These inequalities are costly not just for individuals but for organisations and the wider economy, leading to talent drain and reduced innovation.

Combining gender and ethnicity (see our article on Intersectionality), a recent study by The Fawcett Society highlighted the existence of a "broken rung"—a term describing how women, particularly women of colour, are often unable to make the crucial first step into management, severely limiting their prospects for future promotions. This issue becomes even more critical when we examine the representation of Black women in senior roles: as of 2022, only 1.5% of executive roles in the UK were held by Black women, despite their forming a larger percentage of the overall population.

Uncovering Bias through Data Analysis

At Divrsity, we recognise that uncovering promotion bias requires a nuanced approach that considers both quantitative and qualitative data. That's why our platform is designed to automatically cross-reference responses to the promotion question with demographic information, including gender, ethnicity, age, disability status, and sexual orientation. This intersectional analysis provides a holistic view of an organisation's promotion practices, highlighting any disparities or biases that may be at play.

By comparing the promotion rates across different demographic groups, SPL'ts AI identifies potential red flags and areas of concern. For example, if there is a significant disparity in promotion rates between men and women, or between white employees and ethnic minorities, this could indicate underlying bias or systemic barriers hindering certain groups from advancing. Our system also takes into account other factors such as length of service, performance ratings, and qualifications to ensure a comprehensive understanding of the data.

A Case Study in Promotion Bias

Let's delve into a specific case study from one of our Divrsity surveys to illustrate how our platform uncovers promotion bias. Organisation X, a mid-sized company with 150 employees, utilised the Divrsity survey platform and received responses from 85% of their workforce, a great response rate for this type of initiative. One of the key findings that emerged was related to promotions within the past year. Out of all the respondents, only 15 individuals (10% of the organisation) had been promoted in the last 12 months. At first glance, this might not seem unusual, as organisations typically have limited promotional opportunities annually.

However, when our platform analysed this data through our automated demographic cross-referencing, a startling pattern emerged. All 15 individuals who received promotions identified as white men, despite comprising only 40% of the organisation's overall demographic makeup (with the remaining 60% being women and ethnic minorities). This disparity indicated a potential bias in Organisation X's promotion practices, favouring white male employees over other equally qualified candidates.

The qualitative responses provided additional insights into this issue. Many female and minority ethnic respondents shared anecdotes of feeling overlooked for promotions, with comments like "I've seen less experienced white men get promoted ahead of me" and "there seems to be an old boys' network at play when it comes to career advancement." These verbatim responses, combined with the quantitative data, presented a compelling case for Organisation X to address potential biases in their promotion processes.

Divrsity's Action Plan:

Upon uncovering this bias, our AI-generated Diversity and Inclusion Action Plan provided Organisation X with concrete steps to foster more inclusive promotion practices. Here are some of the key recommendations from our platform:

1. Review Promotion Criteria: Organisation X should reassess their promotion criteria and decision-making processes. This includes examining whether there are hidden biases in how "merit" is defined, such as favouring certain types of work or leadership styles associated with specific genders or ethnic backgrounds.
2. Diverse Interview Panels: To mitigate bias, the organisation was advised to ensure that promotion interview panels consist of diverse members who can provide a range of perspectives and challenge any potential biases that may arise during discussions.
3. Unconscious Bias Training: All managers and employees involved in promotion decisions should undergo unconscious bias training to recognise and address their own biases. This includes understanding how biases influence performance evaluations, which often play a significant role in promotion considerations.
4. Mentorship Programs: The organisation was encouraged to implement mentorship programs that specifically target the advancement of women and ethnic minorities within the company. These programs can provide valuable networking opportunities, skill development, and guidance for aspiring leaders from underrepresented groups.
5. Transparent Promotion Processes: Increasing transparency around promotions can help alleviate concerns about fairness. Organisation X should communicate promotion criteria widely, share success stories of promoted employees across diverse backgrounds, and encourage open conversations about career progression with all staff members.

Sign-up now to gain data-driven workplace insights

Conclusion: Promoting Equity in Promotions

By including a question on promotions in our template surveys and leveraging the power of data analysis, Divrsity is committed to helping UK organisations address bias and create equitable workplaces. Our platform reveals hidden patterns and disparities that might otherwise go unnoticed, providing tangible evidence for companies to take action. Through our automated insights and tailored action plans, businesses can transform their promotion practices to foster inclusivity and ensure that everyone has an equal opportunity to thrive in their careers.

To learn more about how Divrsity is revolutionising Diversity and Inclusion surveys and driving meaningful change across UK workplaces, visit our website and explore the power of data-driven DEI initiatives today!

References

• Fawcett Society. (2022). Closing the Gender Gap: Broken Rung in Promotions. Available at: [https://www.fawcettsociety.org.uk/]
• CIPD. (2021). Race Inclusion Reports: Barriers to Progression. Available at: [https://www.cipd.co.uk/]
• McGregor-Smith, R. (2017). Race in the Workplace: The McGregor-Smith Review. Available at: [https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/]
• McKinsey & Company. (2020). Diversity Wins: How Inclusion Matters. Available at: [https://www.mckinsey.com/]

Sign-up to run your survey today

Related Articles See All Blog Articles

• See the latest set of Diversity and Inclusion Survey Questions
• Read our article on how your company's public face is crucial from a representation perspective.
• If you're a company director, then you should read our comprehensive guide to Diversity and Inclusion for UK Company Directors
• We also offer insights into meaningful changes that you can make to improve the employee experience for the 17% of your organisation that is Neurodiverse, those experiencing menopause, or those with Why Caring Responsibilities should be the 10th Protected Characterstic
• Since we're asking such personal questions, learn how Divrsity is Obsessed with Anonymity
• We love EDI Surveys, but there are Legal and Ethical considerations that you should consider
• Explore the articles in our Diversity Dictionary Series: Representation, Woke, Anti-Racist, Unconscious Bias, Performative DEI, Employee Resource Groups, Equity vs Equality, Intersectionality, Ableism, and Transgender